• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Geographical

Geographical

Official magazine of the Royal Geographical Society (with IBG)

  • Home
  • Briefing
  • Science & Environment
  • Climate
    • Climatewatch
  • Wildlife
  • Culture
  • Geopolitics
    • Geopolitical hotspots
  • Study Geography
    • University directory
    • Masters courses
    • Course guides
      • Climate change
      • Environmental science
      • Human geography
      • Physical geography
    • University pages
      • University of Aberdeen
      • Aberystwyth University
      • Cardiff University
      • University of Chester
      • Edge Hill University
      • The University of Edinburgh
      • Oxford Brookes University
      • Queen Mary University of London
    • Geography careers
      • Charity/non-profit
      • Education & research
      • Environment
      • Finance & consulting
      • Government and Local Government
    • Applications and advice
  • Quizzes
  • Magazine
    • Issue previews
    • Subscribe
    • Manage My Subscription
    • Special Editions
    • Podcasts
    • Geographical Archive
    • Book reviews
    • Crosswords
    • Advertise with us
  • Subscribe

Review: Control by Adam Rutherford

13 May 2022
2 minutes

Katie Burton reviews Adam Rutherford’s new book, Control: The Dark History and Troubling Present of Eugenics, published by W&N


Adam Rutherford’s latest book is split in half. Part one is a fairly straightforward history of the eugenics movement, taking in pioneers in the USA and adopters in Nazi Germany. There’s much to be appalled at, not least the startling extent of the USA’s sterilisation policies which saw 70,000 people sterilized from 1907 until the period after WWII (even then it didn’t come to an end). It’s almost a relief to get to the end of this section and leave behind the deranged minds on display.

Part two looks at eugenics today, or at least attempts to control the genetics of future individuals. As Rutherford says, because of huge accelerations in our understanding of genes and new tools to tinker with them, ‘we face similar debates to those that occurred a century ago,’ when eugenics was enjoying its heyday. Rutherford focuses less on the moral debate – if we could select embryos based on certain traits (high IQ for example) should we? Instead he does what he does best, and asks whether the science behind such attempts even stacks up.

It’s an important question because there are enough people out there who seem to think this type of selection is a good idea. But the answer is, overwhelmingly, no. ‘Our current understanding of genetics does not allow for control of even the supposedly simplest traits,’ says Rutherford, going on to explain why. In doing so, he builds a strong and compelling riposte to all those who would see us merrily tinker with human genes and human lives.

Filed Under: Book Reviews

Protected by Copyscape

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe to Geographical Magazine from just £4.99

Geographical subscriptions

Sign up to our newsletter and get the best of Geographical direct to your inbox

Popular Now

UK against trawling in protected seas in wake of Attenborough film

UK against trawling in protected seas in wake of Attenborough film

QUIZ: Human Geography Trivia

QUIZ: Human Geography Trivia

Concept art of chinese flag and stocks

China: Debt, demographics and a manufacturing slowdown

Protest by Surfers Against Sewage in Falmouth

Paddle-Out Protests: UK water users take to the waves in sewage outrage

Sessen Doji Offering His Life to an Ogre (Oni), circa 1764. Painted by Soga Shōhaku (1730–1781)

Review: Monsterland by Nicholas Jubber

Footer

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • TikTok
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Geographical print magazine cover

Published in the UK since 1935, Geographical is the official magazine of the Royal Geographical Society (with IBG).

Informative, authoritative and educational, this site’s content covers a wide range of subject areas, including geography, culture, wildlife and exploration, illustrated with superb photography.

Click Here for SUBSCRIPTION details

Want to access Geographical on your tablet or smartphone? Press the Apple, Android or PC/Mac image below to download the app for your device

Footer Apple Footer Android Footer Mac-PC

More from Geographical

  • Subscriptions
  • Get our Newsletter
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms & Conditions

Copyright © 2025 · Site by Syon Media