• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Geographical

Geographical

Official magazine of the Royal Geographical Society (with IBG)

  • Geographical Home
  • News
  • Features
  • Opinion
    • Climatewatch
    • Front Lines
  • Podcast
  • Travel
    • Discovering Britain
    • Passport
  • Culture
    • Book reviews
  • Quizzes
    • Crosswords
  • Choose Geography
    • University directory
    • Masters courses
    • Course guides
      • Climate change
      • Environmental science
      • Human geography
      • Physical geography
    • University pages
      • Aberystwyth University
      • Brunel University
      • Cardiff University
      • University of Chester
      • Edge Hill University
      • The University of Edinburgh
      • Newcastle University
      • Nottingham Trent University
      • Oxford Brookes University
      • The University of Plymouth
      • Queen Mary University of London
    • Geography careers
      • Charity/non-profit
      • Education & research
      • Environment
      • Finance & consulting
      • Government and Local Government
    • Applications and advice
  • Magazine
    • Issue previews
    • Subscribe
    • Manage My Subscription
    • Special Editions
    • Geographical Archive
    • Advertise with us
  • Subscribe
    • Direct Debit Changes

Review: Exiles by William Atkins

30 July 2022
2 minutes

view of St Helena looking out to sea
View over St Helena looking out to sea

Exiles is a thoughtful and perceptive exploration of the banished throughout history


Review by Shafik Meghji

‘Exile is more than a geographical concept,’ wrote Palestinian poet and author Mahmoud Darwish. ‘You can be an exile in your homeland, in your own house, in a room.’ It’s a sentiment that chimes with the subjects of William Atkins’ thoughtful and perceptive new book. 

Combining biography, history and travel writing, Exiles focuses on three 19th-century dissidents and the far-flung islands to which they were banished. In 1889, Zulu king Dinuzulu kaCetshwayo, a staunch opponent of British colonialism in his homeland, was convicted of ‘high treason’ and sent to St Helena in the South Atlantic, where Napoleon Bonaparte had been exiled more than half a century earlier. The same year, Lev Shternberg, a militant campaigner against Russian tsarism, was banished to Sakhalin, ‘a large, sparsely populated, coal-rich island’ off the coast of Siberia. In 1873, Louise Michel, a leader of the Paris Commune, a radical socialist government in France, was charged with insurrection, fomenting civil war and murder – among other offences – and exiled to New Caledonia, a French territory in the South Pacific. 

Atkins – whose first book, The Moor, was shortlisted for the Wainwright Prize and whose second, The Immeasurable World, won the Stanford Dolman Travel Book of the Year – explores issues of colonialism and nationalism, freedom and nostalgia, while the personal grief he experiences during the research and writing process underscores a vein of melancholy that runs through the book. On his visits to the three islands, Atkins examines the impact of forced displacement on Dinuzulu, Shternberg and Michel, as well as on the communities that received them. He also weaves in contemporary issues: an independence referendum on New Caledonia, life in a present-day prison on St Helena, the plight of the indigenous Nivkhi people, ejected from their homeland during the 19th century and now hemmed in by oil towns on Sakhalin.   

The ‘imperial exile’ suffered by Dinuzulu, Shternberg and Michel is rarely used today, but Atkins notes that penal colonies and the desire to ‘insulate the metropole against “undesirable’ elements”’ persist, from the US military prison at Guantánamo Bay to the British government’s plan to send people seeking asylum to Rwanda. 

Themes Book Reviews

Protected by Copyscape

Primary Sidebar

SUBSCRIBE

GEOGRAPHICAL WEEKLY LOGO FREE - Sign up to get context, clarity and perspective in a noisy world, every Friday
GIVE A GIFT

Give a year of Geographical - order a gift subscription

Popular Now

December 2026 Geographical Magazine cover

Out now: December 2026’s Geographical Magazine

Sandy beach in Margate, Kent, England

‘Significant deposits of oil’ found on 18 Kent beaches

Oil barrels blue or chemical drums horizontal and vertical

How conflict and El Niño are reshaping global food and oil markets

Marshland in Doñana

The lagoon that fit the bill

Henderson, NV, USA - September 17, 2022: Aerial view at the large-scale Google Data Center - Las Vegas Henderson, NV

AI data centre developers turn to gas-fired power plants

Footer

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • TikTok
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Geographical print magazine cover

Published in the UK since 1935, Geographical is the official magazine of the Royal Geographical Society (with IBG).

Informative, authoritative and educational, this site’s content covers a wide range of subject areas, including geography, culture, wildlife and exploration, illustrated with superb photography.

Click Here for SUBSCRIPTION details

Want to access Geographical on your tablet or smartphone? Press the Apple, Android or PC/Mac image below to download the app for your device

Footer Apple Footer Android Footer Mac-PC

More from Geographical

  • Subscriptions
  • Get our Newsletter
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms & Conditions

Copyright © 2026 · Site by Syon Media