Our directory of things of interest

University Directory

Solving ‘Darwin’s Paradox’

The productive waters surrounding a remote coral reef atoll (Palmyra Atoll) teeming with marine life The productive waters surrounding a remote coral reef atoll (Palmyra Atoll) teeming with marine life Zafer Kizilkaya
09 Apr
2016
An historic phenomenon explaining why fertile coral reefs form as oases in the oceans has finally been proved correct

During Charles Darwin’s many years studying wildlife species around the world, he found himself pondering an observation he couldn’t explain. While most of the open ocean is very low in nutrients, the isolated hotspots where coral reefs form are instead teeming with the energetic resources that stimulate marine ecosystems. ‘He travelled for weeks on end and saw nothing, then came across what he believed to be one of the most diverse ecosystems on the planet,’ explains Gareth Williams, lecturer in Marine Biology at the School of Ocean Sciences, Bangor University. ‘That became known as Darwin’s Paradox.’

Sixty years ago, a hypothesis entitled the ‘Island Mass Effect’ (IME) claimed to have helped solve the famous naturalist’s quandary. The IME proposes that a variety of differing factors work together in the near vicinity of oceanic islands, reinforcing each other and creating a positive feedback system that accumulates and retains the nutrients required to stimulate phytoplankton production and coral reef development. A new paper in the journal Nature Communications (doi:10.1038/ncomms10581) has found the IME to be ‘a near-ubiquitous feature among a majority (91 per cent) of coral reef ecosystems surveyed’, proving the hypothesis correct.

The island creates its own environment that enhances and maintains phytoplankton production within its vicinity

‘The Island Mass Effect,’ continues Williams, senior author of the paper, ‘is the idea that as a reef system starts to form, there are changes in the circulation of flow around that physical structure. The island creates its own environment that enhances and maintains phytoplankton production within its vicinity.’

Some of the most influential factors of the IME include local geomorphology, such as island type and reef slope gradient, both of which create variations in how ‘upwelling’ sweeps nutrients from the deep ocean up into the shallows, providing basal energetic resources for higher trophic levels such as corals and reef fish. ‘Areas that have steep slopes have a less pronounced IME than those that have gradual slopes,’ explains Williams. ‘If you have a very gradual slope, it facilitates the movement of water up into the shallows and with it cooler, nutrient-rich waters from the deep.’ He also highlights the impacts of lagoons in low-lying atolls, which often support large bird populations who bring further nutrients. ‘The flushing of the lagoon system will carry all those biologically-derived nutrients out onto the reef, and cause local phytoplankton enhancement.’

The report also studies the impacts of human-induced nutrient addition, such as agricultural and urban runoff. Williams stresses the need for more research into how these affect coral reef ecology, pointing out that while increases in nutrients initially support reef development, after a certain point it appears to do the opposite. ‘When and how humans become a negative effect is yet to be fully quantified,’ he adds.

This was published in the April 2016 edition of Geographical magazine.

Related items

NEVER MISS A STORY - Follow Geographical on Social

Want to stay up to date with breaking Geographical stories? Join the thousands following us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram and stay informed about the world.

More articles in NATURE...

Oceans

Many scientists believe that jellyfish numbers are increasing, pointing to…

Geophoto

Prepare to be inspired, startled and filled with awe in…

Climate

Excessive use of nitrogen-based fertilisers is contributing to numerous environmental…

Energy

A group of scientists from Edinburgh University has come up…

Geophoto

​This year’s winning environmental photographs show the impacts of the…

Wildlife

A WWF report has revealed that global forest vertebrate populations…

Climate

Yesterday saw one of the biggest public protest movements in…

Climate

On the eve of millions of world citizens going on…

Wildlife

Around 75 million birds are kept as pets in Indonesia,…

Wildlife

Migratory animals are actively adjusting their traditions to cope with…

Climate

How many trees can you plant in a day?

Polar

New analysis of NASA data has led to the discovery…

Climate

Naomi Klein is back and calling for a new world…

Geophoto

The move away from film has meant more pictures being…

Oceans

As the ocean looks set to get busier due to…

Climate

A report details how tropical storms are fuelling the rise…

Wildlife

After years of trials, talks, tweaks and test runs, EarthRanger…

Climate

Nationalism might gain political points in certain parts of the…

Geophoto

With guaranteed sunshine, bright blue skies and not a hint…

Oceans

A review of coral-saving methods is helping communities decide which…