Our directory of things of interest

University Directory

Trophy directed by Christina Clusiau and Shaul Schwarz

Trophy directed by Christina Clusiau and Shaul Schwarz Trophy/Universal Pictures
15 Nov
2017
An emotional and divisive documentary that explores the trophy hunting and ivory farming industries, ‘Trophy’ asks to what extent Africa’s wildlife can be commercialised, or even killed, in order to save endangered species?

If there’s one thing that everyone in Trophy agrees upon – or at least claims to – it’s that the shocking decline in African wildlife, be it rhinos (from 500,000 in 1900 to less than 30,000 today), elephants (from 10,000,000 in 1900 to 350,000 in 2015), lions (less than 20,000 left in the wild) or others, is an urgent issue which warrants an immediate response, as the prospect of genuine extinction for such iconic animals draws nearer and nearer. On everything else, they seem to completely disagree.

This fly-on-the-wall documentary follows a few key characters as they strive to undertake their own particular form of wildlife conservation. What is remarkable is how wide-ranged and often entirely opposing their methods are. There is John Hume, a South African rhino breeder. Christo Homes, a hunting outfitter. Craig Packer, a scientific ecologist. Philip Glass, a trophy hunter. Chris Moore, a Zimbabwean anti-poaching officer. Joe Hosmer, the president of Safari Club International (SCI). Will Travers, the Born Free CEO. These talking heads and others each try to impress upon us, the viewer, why their method of conservation is the best way forward, while disparaging the views of the rest.

humeRhino breeder John Hume argues that he should be allowed to sell his rhino horn to raise money to save the species (Image: Trophy/Universal Pictures)

Hume is one central character who is keen to stress his case, even if it involves shouting down his friends. ‘Give me one animal that’s gone extinct while farmers were breeding it and making money out of it? There’s not one,’ he argues. His 1,400-strong rhino farm sees the animals de-horned every two years to make the animals less desirable to prospective poachers, while simultaneously stockpiling millions of dollars worth of rhino horn (which South African law bans the sale of). ‘If he had an opinion to give to you,’ continues Hume, indicating a large rhino whose horns have just been removed, ‘he would say I’m very happy to sacrifice my horn in order to save my life.’ His deep emotional response to later finding a harrowing rhino massacre, the landscape strewn with their mutilated bodies, certainly suggests – on the face of it – that this is a man who genuinely cares for his animals and wishes to use their commercial potential to save the species from extinction. But is it that simple?

Other proponents of the ‘if it pays, it stays’ model make a far weaker case. At the SCI conference in Las Vegas, President Hosmer’s description of how a $50,000 auction bid to shoot dead a bull elephant, for example, will channel funds into wildlife conservation, leaves more than a bad taste in the mouth, especially with the gun-wielding white-faced grins of the many American hunters bidding for the right to go to Africa and start killing on display.

rhinoRhino numbers have dropped from 500,000 in 1900 to less than 30,000 (Image: Trophy/Universal Pictures)

One such hunter is sheep farmer Philip Glass, from Water Valley, Texas. His dream is to kill each of the ‘big five’ – lion, elephant, buffalo, leopard, and rhino – and he’s willing to pay big money to make it happen. In Namibia, tracking these expensive animals, the anticipation and adrenaline stirs up many emotions, not just those of the Texan hunter. ‘As trophy hunters, we just want the chance to hunt that animal just one time. We really want just one,’ he blubs, a message that fails to be anything other than confusingly selfish and incoherent.

Glass doesn’t seem to be a bad person, just deluded and lost. His strong religious beliefs entitle him – he believes – to not only total dominion over the animal kingdom, but to even utterly reject the concept of evolution. His ability to listen to the deep mournful dying groans of a shot elephant who knows this is the end – to stand there and still feel no regret for what he’s just done – is truly extraordinary, and even quite scary (the obligatory posing for victory photos afterwards might even make you feel sick).

It’s important to distinguish between the subject’s many different silos in a film such as this. Trophy hunting is one, while so-called ‘canned’ hunting, where animals are bred purely to be killed by wealthy hunters, is another. The rhino farming question is different, especially, as Hume is keen to stress, since the animals don’t need to be killed in order to be farmed (unlike most domestic livestock). None of these issues are entirely straightforward, but it’s certainly important to be able to separate them out, as they each present challenges and conundrums that are unique unto themselves. Instead, Trophy chooses to constantly thread them together, a style which blurs the many lines, making it harder for an audience to break them down and fully understand the various arguments being presented.

lion‘Canned’ hunting of lions has become a controversial practice in Africa (Image: Trophy/Universal Pictures)

Craig Packer, experienced conservationist, is perhaps best placed to take the pragmatic, non-idealogical view on these many subjects. While he criticises the fixation on individual animals of many welfare groups, which he feels isn’t helpful in the long run, he is keen to stress the failure of the trophy hunting model to provide the economic benefits needed for conservation in the vast majority of cases where it is undertaken. Rhino farming, however, he almost embraces, hailing South Africa’s ‘success’ in using game ranching to accidentally almost restore the country’s ecosystem.

This is very much at odds with Will Travers’ argument, that nature is not something we can lock up and harvest to make profit off Asia’s peculiar thirst for ivory and other wildlife products. Certainly, briefly allowing a legal market for ivory a decade ago opened the doors to a huge escalation in elephant poaching. Would a legal rhino horn market do the same today? The film gives no concrete information upon which to make a judgement.

There is an immense quantity of uncomfortable viewing in Trophy, and the majority of people will likely find it quite hard going. Clusiau and Schwarz have not held back from showing the sheer volume of death these hunters can produce. Ultimately, unlike more campaign-driven documentaries such as Blackfish, the viewer is left to make up their own mind, to filter the many perspectives and opinions they’ve been presented with to form whatever conclusion they feel most comfortable with. While such perceived neutrality might appear positive on the face of it, a dearth of clear factual information – which would likely help clarify the debate – unfortunately undermines this strategy. While many viewers will realise how obviously bogus the claims of some contributors really are, the possibility that others will believe them is a concern, and a shame given the potential positive legacy of the film.

Trophy is released in cinemas and on DVD and digital download on 17 November

geo line break v3

Free eBooks - Geographical Newsletter

Get the best of Geographical delivered straight to your inbox by signing up to our weekly newsletter and get a free collection of eBooks!

geo line break v3

Subscribe to Geographical!

geo line break v3

Free eBooks - Geographical Newsletter

Sign up for our weekly newsletter today and get a FREE eBook collection!

geo line break v3

University of Winchester

geo line break v3

EDUCATION PARTNERS

Aberystwyth University University of Greenwich The University of Derby

TRAVEL PARTNERS

Ponant

Silversea

Travel the Unknown

DOSSIERS

Like longer reads? Try our in-depth dossiers that provide a comprehensive view of each topic

  • Natural Capital: Putting a price on nature
    Natural capital is a way to quantify the value of the world that nature provides for us – the air, soils, water, even recreational activity. Advocat...
    The human game – tackling football’s ‘slave trade’
    Few would argue with football’s position as the world’s number one sport. But as Mark Rowe discovers, this global popularity is masking a sinister...
    Essential oil?
    Palm oil is omnipresent in global consumption. But in many circles it is considered the scourge of the natural world, for the deforestation and habita...
    When the wind blows
    With 1,200 wind turbines due to be built in the UK this year, Mark Rowe explores the continuing controversy surrounding wind power and discusses the e...
    Hung out to dry
    Wetlands are vital storehouses of biodiversity and important bulwarks against the effects of climate change, while also providing livelihoods for mill...

MORE DOSSIERS

NEVER MISS A STORY - Follow Geographical on Social

Want to stay up to date with breaking Geographical stories? Join the thousands following us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram and stay informed about the world.

More articles in REVIEWS...

Books

by William A. Ewing and Holly Roussell • Thames and…

Books

by Ben Coates • Nicholas Brealey Publishing • £12.99 (paperback)

Books

by Nicholas Crane • Weidenfeld & Nicolson • £12.99 (hardback)

Books

by Mary Robinson • Bloomsbury • £16.99 (hardback)

Books

by Pieter van der Merwe and Jeremy Michell • Bloomsbury • £18.99…

Books

by Simon Reeve • Hodder & Stoughton • £20 (hardback)

Books

by Michael Palin • Hutchinson • £20 (hardback/eBook)

Films

Powerful expedition film, screened at the 2018 Adventure Uncovered Film…

Books

by Laura Locker and Julia Scheele • Icon Books • £12.99 (paperback)

Books

by Patrick Nunn • Bloomsbury • £16.99 (hardback) • £14.99 (eBook)

Books

by Oliver Bullough • Profile Books • £20 (hardback) • £14.99 (eBook)

Books

by Thomas Reinertsen Berg • Hodder & Stoughton • £25 (hardback)

Books

by Adam Rutherford • Weidenfeld & Nicolson • £18.99 (hardback) • £9.99 (eBook)

Films

Ever since 1984, when the first TED conference took place,…

Exhibitions

Annual photography competition at the Natural History Museum celebrates the…

Exhibitions

We all have to live with buildings, but getting the…

Books

by Bruno Latour • Polity Books • £12.99 (hardback)

Books

edited by Fearghal O’Nuallain • Summersdale • £9.99 (paperback)

Books

by Francis Fukuyama • Profile Books • £16.99 (hardback) • £14.99 (eBook)