Air failure: long-running Mexico City scheme fails to reduce pollution

A familiar sight: bumper-to-bumper traffic on the streets of Mexico City A familiar sight: bumper-to-bumper traffic on the streets of Mexico City ChameleonsEye / Shutterstock, Inc.
09 Feb
2017
They have been in place for nearly a decade, but Mexico City’s Saturday driving restrictions have had negligible impacts on solving the megacity’s air pollution crisis

There can be no doubt that the 21st century has witnessed a radical renaissance of Mexico’s capital, Mexico City. Where once its rapidly growing population (now around 21 million people) and precarious geographical positioning (at 2,200m above sea level, atop an unstable lake basin) were creating severe shortages of clean water, electricity, housing, and sewage facilities, a series of economic and cultural changes have transformed the city into a modern cosmopolitan metropolis.

Like many cities around the world – from London to Beijing, Paris to Delhi – Mexico City does, however, continue to battle toxic air pollution; a filthy, thick layer of smog which blights the skyline and fills the lungs of millions of residents every day. Globally, the World Health Organization estimates that around three million deaths annually are due to ambient (outdoor) air pollution, and only one person in ten lives in a city that complies with the WHO Air Quality Guidelines.

The topography of Mexico City is particularly harsh; its location within a ring of rangy mountains traps the tiny particulate matter, carbon monoxide (CO), nitric oxide (NO), nitrogen dioxide (NO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx) and other toxins, preventing them from escaping into the wider environment. This results in particulate levels (PM10) that are three to four times higher than New York, Los Angeles, or São Paulo. As with other global cities, there are a variety of sources for these pollutants, but one of the key culprits clogs the city streets every single day: the car. Vehicles in Mexico City are believed to be responsible for 99 per cent of carbon monoxide, and 82 per cent of nitrogen oxide emissions.

Recognising the seriously adverse effects that millions of private cars were having on the megacity’s atmosphere, Mexico City became one of the first in the world to implement driving restrictions based on individual car licence plates in November 1989. Known as Hoy No Circula, the scheme bans drivers from using their vehicles one day per week, depending on the last digit of the vehicle’s plate (for example, vehicles with a license plate ending in ‘5’ or ‘6’ cannot not be used on Mondays), and drivers caught violating the rules (they are fairly easy to spot, given the police know exactly what number to look out for each day) must pay a hefty fine and their vehicles are impounded for 48 hours. In July 2008, the scheme was extended to include Saturdays, and plenty of cities subsequently followed Mexico City's example; more than 145 million people now live in cities with license-plate based driving restrictions, most recently Delhi in January 2016.

Drivers everywhere have a revealed preference for fast and convenient transportation, so it can be difficult to get them to switch to public transportation

Unfortunately, the effects of the ban appear to be far less promising than such a successful global take-up might otherwise suggest. A 2008 study concluded that ‘there is no evidence that the program improved air quality,’ stating that it ‘engendered a relative increase in air pollution during weekends and non-peak weekdays,’ but that there was ‘no evidence of an absolute improvement in air quality during any period for any pollutant’. Now, a follow-up study by the same institution, the Haas School of Business, University of California, Berkeley, has examined the Saturday extension, and discovered that, despite hopes the scheme would reduce air pollution levels by over 15 per cent, the expansion had virtually no discernible effect.

‘Saturday driving restrictions are a flawed policy,’ says Lucas W Davis, an associate professor at UC Berkeley’s Haas School of Business, and lead author of the study. ‘It’s a big hassle for people and does not improve air quality. People have found other ways to get around the driving restrictions. Some purchase multiple cars, others take taxis or Uber.’

Davis analysed hourly air pollution data from 29 monitoring stations around Mexico City between 2005 and 2012 and discovered no noticeable decrease in all pollutants as a result of the driving restrictions. Analysis of public transport rider numbers – on city buses, electric buses, and light rail – also revealed no significant increase as a result of the ban. He argues that residents continued to drive, just in alternative cars, or by using ‘taxis’ such as Uber.

tableGlobal license-plate city driving restrictions (Image: Lucas W Davis/Haas School of Business, University of California, Berkeley)

These conclusions cast something of a shadow on the effectiveness of licence-plate driving restrictions around the world to combat life-threatening air pollution, and, in a small way, the larger issue of climate change. Davis doesn’t entirely despair of the usage of such measures, however he points out that it is far from a one-size-fits-all solution to this worldwide problem.

‘The effectiveness of driving restrictions in other places will depend on the available substitutes and the willingness of drivers to switch to lower-emissions forms of transportation,’ he stresses. ‘However, drivers everywhere have a revealed preference for fast and convenient transportation, so it can be difficult to get them to switch to public transportation. Moving forward, this is not going to get any easier with the increased global availability of taxi-like services like Uber.’

Share this story...

Submit to FacebookSubmit to Google PlusSubmit to Twitter

Related items

Geographical Week

Get the best of Geographical delivered straight to your inbox every Friday.

Subscribe Today

Target Ovarian Cancer

EDUCATION PARTNERS

Aberystwyth UniversityUniversity of GreenwichThe University of Winchester

TRAVEL PARTNERS

Ponant

Silversea

Travel the Unknown

DOSSIERS

Like longer reads? Try our in-depth dossiers that provide a comprehensive view of each topic

  • The Nuclear Power Struggle
    The UK appears to be embracing nuclear, a huge U-turn on government policy from just two years ago. Yet this seems to be going against the grain globa...
    The Air That We Breathe
    Cities the world over are struggling to improve air quality as scandals surrounding diesel car emissions come to light and the huge health costs of po...
    Diabetes: The World at Risk
    Diabetes is often thought of as a ‘western’ problem, one linked to the developed world’s overindulgence in fatty foods and chronic lack of physi...
    National Clean Air Day
    For National Clean Air Day, Geographical brings together stories about air pollution and the kind of solutions needed to tackle it ...
    REDD+ or Dead?
    The UN-backed REDD+ (Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation) scheme, under which developing nations would be paid not to cut dow...

MORE DOSSIERS

NEVER MISS A STORY - follow Geographical

Want to stay up to date with breaking Geographical stories? Join the thousands following us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram and stay informed about the world.

More articles in PLACES...

Mapping

Where in America can the country's various hate groups be…

Water

The southern US state is sinking twice as fast as…

Cities

An increase in visitors is putting severe strain on Iceland’s…

Cities

Air pollution campaigners hold a disco roadblock, but can it…

Cities

Cities the world over are struggling to improve air quality…

Forests

HSBC has requested a Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil investigation…

Mapping

Benjamin Hennig explores visions of a world made bright by humanity

Forests

The EU has asked the European court to authorise an…

Forests

Was last year’s El Niño a practice run for future…

Cities

Far from being separate threats, scientists have found links between…

Mountains

Is the official height of Mount Everest accurate?

Mapping

Where in the world is the highest density of languages?…

Cities

The next stage in autonomous vehicles is hoping to transform…

Mapping

Geographical’s resident data cartographer presents a true picture of the…

Water

What impact could an unprecedented incident of ‘river piracy’ have…

Mountains

Norway is to undercut a mountainous peninsula to create the…

Mapping

Benjmain Hennig explores global mortality with maps

Water

Last winter’s cold conditions contributed a further influx of road…

Water

As one of America’s biggest cities, supplying clean drinking water…

Cities

Cape Town’s Foreshore Freeway Bridge has been left unfinished for…