Our directory of things of interest

University Directory

Bull fights: cultural clash in Catalonia

Catalonia's ban on bullfighting has been overturned by the Spanish courts Catalonia's ban on bullfighting has been overturned by the Spanish courts Naturesports
28 Nov
2016
A Spanish cultural divide has been ripped open by the overturning of Catalonia’s bullfighting ban

Back in July 2010, animal rights activists in Catalonia were celebrating a significantly symbolic legal victory. Bullfighting had just been outlawed by the Catalan parliament, following the submission of a 180,000-signature petition. A year later, 20,000 spectators crammed into Barcelona’s La Monumental – the one remaining Catalan bullring – as it hosted its last ever fight before being closed and converted into a bullfighting museum. It was a bold declaration of autonomy and self-governance for the aspiring independent state (it became the second Spanish autonomous community to ban the practice, after the Canary Islands in 1991). Meanwhile, much of the rest of Spain, where bullfighting remains popular, mourned Catalonia’s ‘ignorant and culturally insensitive rejection’ of a ‘proud Spanish tradition’.

Bullfighting is rejected because it is associated with an old-fashioned vision of Spain

However, the tables were turned last month when Spain’s Constitutional Court declared the Catalan ban to be in violation of a national law protecting bullfighting as an essential part of Spain’s cultural heritage, thereby deeming the ban illegal. The response in Catalonia has been one of defiance, with hundreds of protestors marching in the streets of Barcelona, and condemnation by local Catalan politicians. ‘There’ll be no bullfights in Catalonia, regardless of what the Constitutional Court says,’ responded Josep Rulls, Catalan Land Minister.

‘Bullfighting is rejected because it is associated with an old-fashioned vision of Spain,’ explains Dr Andrew Dowling, Senior Lecturer in Catalan and Spanish History at Cardiff University. He points out that correbous (bull runs) still take place in Catalonia with, as he terms it, equally ‘insensitive treatment of animals. There is an ever greater psychological and cultural process of distancing underway [in Catalonia] from that which is seen as “Spanish”. Secondary are the ethical and moral arguments about bullfighting.’

This was published in the December 2016 edition of Geographical magazine.

Related items

NEVER MISS A STORY - Follow Geographical on Social

Want to stay up to date with breaking Geographical stories? Join the thousands following us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram and stay informed about the world.

More articles in PEOPLE...

Cultures

Photographer Andrew Newey visits the world’s highest permanently inhabited plateau, where farmers…

Refugees

The Taliban’s recent takeover of Afghanistan prompted a new refugee…

I’m a Geographer

Rose Abramoff is a climate scientist who recently made headlines…

Development

Mark Rowe reflects on the changing nature of overseas aid and…

Cultures

The end of human-powered rickshaws has long been predicted in…

Explorers

The wreck of Endurance, Ernest Shackleton's Antarctic expedition ship, has…

Cultures

Faizal Farook investigates the relationship between Britain’s diverse ethnic-minority communities…

Cultures

Following the shocking discovery of thousands of unmarked graves at…

Development

While the world debates the best ways to reduce emissions…

Cultures

The Ganges is one of the most polluted rivers on…

Cultures

A new caviar-production venture could transform Thailand into a major…

People

In cities around the world, the geography of homosexuality is…

Cultures

In Morocco, people don’t Uber. Instead, they pile into so-called…

Development

Oysters play a hugely important role in ecosystems by filtering…

People

Our Christmas Gift Guide is back for 2021, featuring eco-friendly,…

Cultures

Vitali Vitaliev takes a tour of the small town of Montreuil-sur-Mer…

Cultures

With the market for Muslim travellers growing at pace, holiday-makers…

Cultures

Three years ago, a violent storm devastated northern Italy’s iconic…

Explorers

Carnivorous-plant expert Mateusz Wrazidlo set out to fulfil his dearest…