Our directory of things of interest

University Directory

The chaos factor

  • Written by  Paul F Steinberg
  • Published in Opinions
Soldiers lined up in Bangkok, Thailand Soldiers lined up in Bangkok, Thailand Chris Singshinsuk
08 May
2015
There’s a need to take political instability around the world far more seriously when devising strategies for protecting our planet

Nowhere is this more apparent than in the efforts underway to address the effects of climate change through a global treaty to be signed in Paris in December.

Policymakers have rallied around the idea of reducing atmospheric carbon dioxide by paying landowners in poor countries to protect their forests. As a supplement to emissions cuts in industrialised countries, forest-based carbon capture holds great promise. But in the rush to craft an agreement that includes developing countries, there is a question no one is asking: Is sustainable governance of forests even possible within political systems that are themselves unsustainable, experiencing chronic turnover through wars, constitutional crises and coups?

Placing tropical forests under the protective umbrella of the climate treaty makes perfect sense. Forests absorb about a third of the carbon released by burning fossil fuels, but most of that is offset by deforestation in Africa, Asia, and Latin America. The UN’s REDD+ program (Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation) can help rebalance the global carbon budget while compensating farmers in the tropics for the environmental services they provide. Environmental treaties, however, are only effective if they change the rules governing behaviour on the ground. Energy and transportation policies, timber company contracts and local land use agreements – these rules decide whether forests survive, who benefits from their use, and whether we can combat global problems while promoting local livelihoods.

Almost half the world’s tropical forests are in countries plagued by violent conflict

To be effective, social rules must have a measure of staying power. It is no coincidence that the only system of payments for forest conservation to last more than a decade is found in Latin America’s most stable democracy – Costa Rica. Costa Ricans created their innovative program, piece by piece, from the 1969 Forestry Law to ongoing policy experimentation today.

In most of the world, political and economic upheaval are the norm, upending efforts to institutionalise sustainability. From 1970 to 2010, one in every six countries eligible for REDD+ funding experienced a complete collapse in central state authority for one or more years. Between 1971 and 2009, 111 successful military coups took place in 36 percent of these countries. Almost half the world’s tropical forests are in countries plagued by violent conflict.

Deeper changes are wrought by turnover in entire constitutional structures, including shifts between democratic and authoritarian regimes. From 1981 to 2010, 329 constitutional replacements occurred in 112 REDD-eligible countries. Over two-thirds of the delegations from developing countries that signed the original climate treaty in 1992 represented political regimes that simply no longer exist.

Even peaceful transitions can produce high staff turnover and the churning of bureaucratic structures. Indonesia, with Asia’s largest tropical forest area, created a cabinet-level REDD+ agency in late 2013; by January of this year it was gone, dissolved by newly elected President.

So what can be done? While it’s not within the power of the international community to halt instability, we can mitigate some of its more pernicious effects. National REDD+ initiatives should be implemented not only by fragile new agencies created for this purpose, but through networks of organisations that will advocate for policy continuity. Managing political uncertainty can be likened to a diversified investment portfolio. Political diversification entails an explicit emphasis on multi-party constituencies, multi-agency collaboration, geographic spread, and the involvement of powerful stakeholders from the governmental, private, and non-profit sectors.

Over two-thirds of the delegations from developing countries that signed the original climate treaty in 1992 represented political regimes that simply no longer exist

Other approaches could include contract provisions requiring extra insurance – in the form of additional forest hectares planted or protected – in countries that have historically experienced high institutional turnover. Countries with credible plans for institutional resilience could command a premium in global carbon markets.

Bureaucracies are supposed to foster policy continuity, but the quality of governance varies widely throughout the tropics. Capacity building efforts should promote system-wide reforms to reduce political patronage and strengthen the civil service. Brazil has shown that watchdog agencies like its Ministério Público can, given sufficient resources, improve public sector accountability and reduce corruption.

In the race to innovate for a greener planet, it’s easy for those of us in stable democracies to take the durability of our institutions for granted. If developing countries are to play a proactive role in protecting the climate, officials must tap the political acumen of those on the ground who understand how to sustain reforms amid chaos.

Paul F Steinberg is Professor of Political Science and Environmental Policy at Harvey Mudd College and author of Who Rules the Earth? How Social Rules Shape Our Planet and Our Lives.

This article was published in the May 2015 edition of Geographical Magazine

Related items

Subscribe to Geographical!

geo line break v3

Free eBooks - Geographical Newsletter

Sign up for our weekly newsletter today and get a FREE eBook collection!

geo line break v3

University of Winchester

geo line break v3

EDUCATION PARTNERS

Aberystwyth University University of Greenwich The University of Derby

TRAVEL PARTNERS

Ponant

Silversea

Travel the Unknown

DOSSIERS

Like longer reads? Try our in-depth dossiers that provide a comprehensive view of each topic

  • Natural Capital: Putting a price on nature
    Natural capital is a way to quantify the value of the world that nature provides for us – the air, soils, water, even recreational activity. Advocat...
    The human game – tackling football’s ‘slave trade’
    Few would argue with football’s position as the world’s number one sport. But as Mark Rowe discovers, this global popularity is masking a sinister...
    Essential oil?
    Palm oil is omnipresent in global consumption. But in many circles it is considered the scourge of the natural world, for the deforestation and habita...
    London: a walk in the park
    In the 2016 London Mayoral election, the city’s natural environment was high on the agenda. Geographical asks: does the capital have a green future,...
    Alien views
    The tabloids would have us believe that immigrants are taking our houses, our jobs, our school places and our hospital beds. But a close reading of th...

MORE DOSSIERS

NEVER MISS A STORY - Follow Geographical on Social

Want to stay up to date with breaking Geographical stories? Join the thousands following us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram and stay informed about the world.

More articles in OPINIONS...

Opinions

Using computer simulations, cultural evolution researcher Alex Mesoudi analyses the…

Opinions

Architect Kelvin Campbell presents the case for ‘making massive small…

Opinions

Tim Brookes is the founder of the Endangered Alphabets Project …

Opinions

Encouraging beavers’ spread will only benefit the environment – on…

Opinions

City centres in the UK and other countries, could be…

Opinions

Is the world going through another transfer of power? Julian…

Opinions

It’s time to stop relying on traditional commercial methods when…

Opinions

Lack of pollination of commercial crops is an issue of…

Opinions

Where does aid go from here? Pablo Yanguas calls for…

Opinions

Would North Korea give up its nuclear weapons? Would an…

Opinions

It’s time to tackle the hidden superbug menace in India’s…

Opinions

Earlier this month, an international sustainability conference brought together 400…

Opinions

On the Southern edge of the remote Kongsfjorden (King’s Fjord)…

Opinions

Exploring outdoors and in different places is important throughout our…

Opinions

Something has gone badly wrong with our planet’s oceans. If…

Opinions

Taking a wider look at Brexit from a geography standpoint

Opinions

The blockade of imports into Qatar by its Gulf neighbours…

Opinions

Is it time for a new and radical approach to alleviating…

Opinions

Plastic-free aisles in our local supermarkets may just be key…