CITES: Sharks and rays win further protection

  • Written by  Harriet Constable
  • Published in Wildlife
Thresher shark in Malapascua, Philippines Thresher shark in Malapascua, Philippines nicolasvoisin44
04 Oct
2016
Parties at the CITES conference in Johannesburg voted for proposals to list devil rays, thresher sharks and silky sharks under Appendix II, offering them better protection from international trade following unsustainable fishing for their fins in recent years

The small, picture perfect island of Malapascua in the Philippines had seemed a lost cause to its inhabitants just a few years ago. Unsustainable and damaging fishing methods, including the use of dynamite and trawling, had ruined the ecosystem. Previously a fishing village, now there was nothing. To add insult to injury, November 2013 brought Typhoon Haiyan, one of the strongest tropical cyclones ever recorded, which destroyed large amounts of infrastructure on the island. This, teemed with the loss of fish in the oceans, cost the locals their livelihoods.

The island had just one saving grace which it could turn to in hopes of saving its inhabitants’ lives, and rebuilding the island: sharks.

Sail just a few kilometres east from the island and you will reach Monad Shoal, a natural cleaning station for fish and the only place in the world where thresher sharks can be seen regularly. These long-tailed creatures come to clean their gills, skin and mouths using the seamount.

Anna Oposa, of Save Philippines Seas, and a small team were able to turn things around for the island by protecting its sharks. ‘I received an award to establish shark and marine sanctuary and moved to Malapascua in 2012,’ she says. ‘We started by training people on marine science and engaging youth about marine ecology, teaching them that it’s not just the dive community that can benefit from saving the sharks.’

The economics are simple: the more sharks the island has, the more money it makes from avid tourists keen to see them in the oceans. Dennis Bryan Bait-it, a dive instructor in Malapascua, now gets a sustainable income from thresher shark tourism. ‘Everyone on the island is somehow related to thresher shark tourism,’ he emphasises. ‘There are dive shark managers who started off as fishermen. People are happy because their children can go to school.’

Yet this positive tourism could be lost in a heartbeat. Thresher shark populations have declined more than 70 per cent worldwide, largely due to unsustainable fishing methods and a huge demand for their fins in Asian cuisine.

Sharks are facing a global mortality crisis, with 100 million killed every year. For many species, it’s impossible for them to recover from continuously declining populations

In 2014, Oposa and Bryan Bait-it made a group called Friends of Sharks – turning local fishermen into fish wardens, who are empowered to protect the oceans and ensure no illegal fishing of thresher sharks is taking place. The wardens don’t just patrol, they also carry out information campaigns, speaking to neighbours and explaining the benefits of protecting the shoal and marine parks.

However, more needs to be done if they are to truly protect this species and keep their positive tourism efforts going. Therefore, Oposa and Bryan Bait-it chose to attend CITES CoP17 to lobby for thresher sharks to be moved to Appendix II, offering them more protection.

‘A listing on CITES Appendix II ensures that all thresher fins that are traded internationally are from sustainably managed fisheries that do not harm the status of these species populations in the wild,’ explains Luke Warwick, director of the global shark conservation campaign at The Pew Charitable Trusts. ‘Additionally, any catch of these species [has] to be accurately recorded. Management of shark species is almost non-existent – so these listings [will] have a huge impact on recorded data.’

It’s not just thresher sharks that need further protection, according to Warwick. ‘Sharks are facing a global mortality crisis, with 100 million killed every year,’ he says. ‘For many species, it’s impossible for them to recover from continuously declining populations. For instance, silky and thresher sharks can take over ten years to mature and produce pups, with threshers only having one or two pups every other year. Add to that the unsustainable declines these species are facing – at least 70 per cent everywhere they are found, and sometimes as high as 90 per cent as with the silky sharks in the Indian Ocean – and these sharks are headed towards extinction.’

For Oposa and Bryan Bait-it, the impact of the CITES listing is personal. ‘Thresher sharks are fundamental to Malapascua tourism,’ they said, before the vote. ‘If they get on Appendix II it automatically protects them nationally. That’s why we’re trying to do this.’

devil rayDevil Rays will now be listed on CITES Appendix II (Image: Michaelpuche)

The discussion on whether to list devil rays, thresher sharks and silky sharks was a highly anticipated event. In previous years, CITES members had already voted to list five commercially valuable sharks – including the great hammerhead and the oceanic white tip – and all manta rays, and it is widely agreed by conservationists that the listing is helping these species to survive, especially given the intense demand for their fins in Asia.

The Maldives was one of the first countries to advocate for the listing of silky sharks on Appendix II. ‘Here in Africa the conservation and proper management of the big five species are crucial... in the Maldives, silky sharks are among our big five. Without them we would lose millions of dollars in tourism revenue.’

Sri Lanka and Ethiopia were also among the countries to speak out in favour of the listing, with Sri Lanka talking of the ‘strong declines [of sharks] in our waters... driven by demand for their fins.’ The Ethiopian delegate stated, ‘My kid gave me a message to vote for sharks. Ethiopia supports the range states who are calling on all parties to assist them in preserving their natural resources.’

A number of parties also argued against the listing of these species, including Qatar, Japan and Iceland. The Qatar delegate argued, ‘many people on the coast are depending [on sharks] for protein. Inclusion in Appendix II may affect them.’

Sharks and rays around the world are being overfished for a thriving global market, yet only a tiny fraction of these species are regulated in international trade

Japan questioned whether CITES protection could really help the species. ‘CITES should evaluate the effect of the previous Appendix II listings – the listing of silky shark will not [achieve conservation],’ said its delegate, arguing that other sharks are listed on Appendix II and yet they are still unsustainably harvested from the seas.

Iceland voiced concerns that an Appendix II listing might result in the opposite to the intended effect, and rather than protect these species, could put them in more danger. ‘A listing is more likely to result in lack of reporting or even discarding... Stocks would suffer. [Instead of the Appendix II listing] countries should be encouraged to take suitable measures to manage the sharks.’

Nevertheless, over two thirds of the members voted for all species to be listed, and the proposals passed in the Johannesburg conference.

In response to the decision, Amie Brautigam, Sharks and Rays Coordinator at the Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS) said, ‘Today, CITES took its next concrete steps – begun in 1994 – to conserve sharks and rays, among the most threatened animals on the planet. The global trade in shark and ray parts and products is nearing $1billion in value per year and is provisioned by shark and ray fisheries that are landing more than 800,000 metric tons of these animals per year. Sharks and rays around the world are being overfished for a thriving global market, yet only a tiny fraction of these species are regulated in international trade. We hope governments follow through with today’s decisions to extend CITES regulation to devil rays, thresher sharks, and the silky shark.’

The decision will be finalised during plenary discussions at CITES over the next two days.

Read Harriet Constable’s report from Johannesburg on everything you need to know about the ten-day CITES conference, the decision to upgrade critically endangered pangolins to Appendix I, or find out from Klaus Dodds about the complicated geopolitical issues associated with CITES wildlife conservation and extinction.


For more great content like this, sign up below for our FREE weekly newsletter. The best of Geographical in your inbox, every Friday afternoon!

 
 
 

Share this story...

Submit to FacebookSubmit to Google PlusSubmit to Twitter

Related items

Geographical Week

Get the best of Geographical delivered straight to your inbox every Friday.

Subscribe Today

EDUCATION PARTNERS

Aberystwyth UniversityUniversity of GreenwichThe University of Winchester

TRAVEL PARTNERS

Ponant

Silversea

Travel the Unknown

DOSSIERS

Like longer reads? Try our in-depth dossiers that provide a comprehensive view of each topic

  • The Air That We Breathe
    Cities the world over are struggling to improve air quality as scandals surrounding diesel car emissions come to light and the huge health costs of po...
    Diabetes: The World at Risk
    Diabetes is often thought of as a ‘western’ problem, one linked to the developed world’s overindulgence in fatty foods and chronic lack of physi...
    National Clean Air Day
    For National Clean Air Day, Geographical brings together stories about air pollution and the kind of solutions needed to tackle it ...
    The Nuclear Power Struggle
    The UK appears to be embracing nuclear, a huge U-turn on government policy from just two years ago. Yet this seems to be going against the grain globa...
    REDD+ or Dead?
    The UN-backed REDD+ (Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation) scheme, under which developing nations would be paid not to cut dow...

MORE DOSSIERS

NEVER MISS A STORY - follow Geographical

Want to stay up to date with breaking Geographical stories? Join the thousands following us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram and stay informed about the world.

More articles in NATURE...

Energy

Could human waste one day be fuelling our homes and…

Geophoto

Every year, the LPOTY awards celebrate the best in Britain’s…

Climate

At the 23rd Convention of the Parties (COP) climate change…

Oceans

Knowing where past coral reefs existed is a crucial component…

Oceans

Numerous low-lying Pacific islands have disappeared under rising seas

Oceans

In this exclusive film for Geographical, see how an unusually…

Climate

Marco Magrini considers why the recent devastation caused by hurricanes…

Geophoto

Country borders are some of the most controlled environments on…

Wildlife

Nature reserves and protected areas in Germany have lost 76…

Oceans

An investigation into shark fins and ray gills sold in…

Climate

Geographical’s regular look at the world of climate change. This…

Wildlife

The rapid spread of Asian hornets is likely to make…

Energy

Europe provides more than €112billion (£97billion) in subsidies to fossil…

Oceans

A study of various fish populations has found dramatic reductions…

Geophoto

The seasonal changes of September promise much photographic potential for…

Oceans

Shipping traffic can increase lightning strikes, according to a pioneering…

Polar

New documentary travels to remote Antarctica to unpack the complex…

Oceans

The deaths of these majestic creatures had remained an unsolved…

Wildlife

Over a two-year period, a new species of plant or…

Wildlife

As part of New Zealand’s plan to cull millions of…