COP 23: US states, cities, politicians and business leaders defy Trump

  • Written by  Matt Maynard
  • Published in Climate
COP 23: US states, cities, politicians and business leaders defy Trump UNFCCC
15 Nov
At the 23rd Convention of the Parties (COP) climate change conference in Bonn, taking place 6-17 November, a sub-group of concerned US policy makers and politicians are currently challenging their President’s inaction

The annual COP meetings have been gathering both urgency and direction in the last two years. At the landmark Paris Agreement in 2015, all world nations (besides Syria and Nicaragua) agreed to aim to keep global temperature rise this century well below 2°C (compared to pre-industrial levels).

On 1 June this year, however, President Trump reneged on the US’s commitments made during the Obama administration, declaring ‘we’re getting out’. Syria and Nicaragua have both since promised to sign up. As a result, the beleaguered official US delegation at COP23, derided for their awkward advocacy of ‘clean coal’, arrived at the convention looking isolated and backward.

Step in UN Special Envoy for Cities and Climate Change – Michael Bloomberg. Alongside Californian governor Jerry Brown, the two men formed the ‘We Are Still In’ declaration last June following Trump’s announcement. The goal was to ensure that American states, cities and business are not left behind, and to demonstrate that the US continues to be a world leader on climate change by adhering to the requirements of the Paris Agreement.

As non-state actors, Bloomberg and Brown were unable to represent US interests in an official capacity at Bonn. But multi-billionaire Bloomberg is a man who knows how to host a party. At the privately-funded Climate Action Pavilion on the outskirts of COP23, he and Brown launched ‘America’s Pledge’ this Saturday to a packed and expectant crowd. While inaction continues on a Federal level in the US, Bloomberg and Brown’s goal before 2025 is to reduce US economy-wide emissions by 26 per cent to 28 per cent compared to 2005 levels.

Networks supporting the Paris Agreement across the USNetworks supporting the Paris Agreement across the US (Source: America’s Pledge)

Why America’s Pledge matters

For logistical reasons, COP23 is being held in Bonn, Germany. The actual ‘host’ nation in 2017, however, is Fiji – a country severely affected by sea level rise, the increased intensity of cyclones and warmer temperatures associated with climate change.

In his welcoming remarks, the Fijian prime minister and incoming COP president Frank Bainimarama embraced the presence of the US sub-delegation stating that, ‘without the non-state actors, we will fall short of the objectives set by the parties.’ Perhaps referring to the rift that President Trump created by abandoning the Paris Agreement, he referred to Talanoa – the word in many Pacific languages for ‘honest constructive dialogue.’ He invited all parties to embrace it during the convention, adding, ‘the Talanoa spirit is not just about being nice to everyone; although respect is essential.’

Since June this year, Bloomberg and Brown have been in dialogue with businesses, tribes, city mayors, universities and states across the US. They now have more than 2,500 signatories for the We Are Still In declaration. The America’s Pledge Phase 1 Report, released to coincide with COP23, details how Bloomberg and Brown now plan to wield their signatories’ power to tackle climate change, and act beyond the auspices of the Federal government.

And power they have. China and the United States are the only two countries whose GDP is higher than the support Bloomberg and Brown have already garnered from combined US non-state actors since June. When they took to the stage this Saturday morning in Bonn, it is no surprise that many of the 197 Parties of the Paris Framework were present and listening.

GDPs of countries and US States supporting Paris AgreementGDPs of countries and US States supporting Paris Agreement (Source: America’s Pledge)

What does America’s Pledge offer?

In the Climate Action Pavilion, Bloomberg said of renewable energy that, ‘thanks to the falling price of coal and solar, coal no longer makes any economic sense.’ Innovation in vehicle batteries and solar energy generation is credited in the America’s Pledge report with reducing their respective cost since 2010 by 80 per cent.

‘The false promise of jobs coming back in coal,’ he went on say, ‘is a sad fraud on miners who need help to transition to a new economy so they and their families can have a future, rather than being a pawn in a political reality show.’

Earlier in proceedings at the pavilion, the powerful We Are Still In signatory member Walmart had been invited to showcase. Laura Phillips, the retail giant’s senior vice president of sustainability, said that in the last ten years ‘investments in renewables have saved [Walmart] a lot of money.’ Besides strengthening business goals, Phillips explained that the $210billion-multinational has found that by installing onsite solar energy and investing in the climate ‘it is also good for our communities.’

The false promise of jobs coming back in coal is a sad fraud on miners who need help to transition to a new economy

Governor Jerry Brown spoke to the incremental ‘ratchet mechanism’ built into America’s Pledge and the wider Paris Agreement. Full implementation of the current Paris Agreement would still be estimated to cause warming between an extremely dangerous 2.8°C, and a catastrophic 4.5°C.

‘Is it enough? No!’ Brown said about America’s Pledge. ‘We are not at the point where we are reducing emissions globally, and we have to do a lot more.’

This first report corroborates the opportunities for deeper emission reductions by US states, cities and businesses. These will be analysed further in the more comprehensive Phase 2 Report in 2018.

Michael Bloomberg and Frank BainimaramaMichael Bloomberg and Frank Bainimarama (Image: UNFCCC)

Does America’s Pledge go far enough?

Not everyone at the Climate Action Pavilion thought that America’s Pledge had filled the void left by Trump’s rejection of the Paris Agreement. Brown was heckled repeatedly during his speech by protestors, including Native American groups, over continued fracking in California.

Patricia Espinosa, executive secretary of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, struck a conciliatory note at the end of proceedings. Her presence, alongside COP president Bainimarama, was an affirmation of the work America’s Pledge has already done. She concluded by applauding its efforts and reaffirming that ‘the climate change agenda can not be delivered by governments alone.’

The world is on the road to hell, unless we make a radical turn towards a more sustainable path

On Monday 13 November, Brown reappeared emboldened and even more brazen to say, ‘the world is on the road to hell, unless we make a radical turn towards a more enlightened, sustainable path.’ A report published overnight, the Global Carbon Budget, has shown that after five years of slowing or no growth in CO2 emissions, projections for global emissions in 2017 predict a renewed increase of two per cent.

Brown has also announced a ‘Global Climate Action Summit’ for September 2018 in San Francisco. Meanwhile, Bloomberg poured scorn on the disastrous pro-fossil fuel groups sent out to bat by the official US delegation in the afternoon – calling their advocacy of coal at a climate summit, ‘like promoting tobacco at a cancer summit.’

At COP23 there are two very different American delegations, with very different ideologies, motivations and agendas. Yet in spite of how far the two US delegations seem to be drifting, common ground and honest dialogue must soon be found in the global effort to confront climate change. After all, in the rather refreshing words of Bainimarama, ‘we are all in the same canoe.’

red line


Geographical Week

Get the best of Geographical delivered straight to your inbox by signing up to our free weekly newsletter!

red line

Related items

Geographical Week

Get the best of Geographical delivered straight to your inbox every Friday.


Subscribe Today


Aberystwyth University University of Greenwich The University of Winchester




Travel the Unknown


Like longer reads? Try our in-depth dossiers that provide a comprehensive view of each topic

  • National Clean Air Day
    For National Clean Air Day, Geographical brings together stories about air pollution and the kind of solutions needed to tackle it ...
    The Air That We Breathe
    Cities the world over are struggling to improve air quality as scandals surrounding diesel car emissions come to light and the huge health costs of po...
    Diabetes: The World at Risk
    Diabetes is often thought of as a ‘western’ problem, one linked to the developed world’s overindulgence in fatty foods and chronic lack of physi...
    The Nuclear Power Struggle
    The UK appears to be embracing nuclear, a huge U-turn on government policy from just two years ago. Yet this seems to be going against the grain globa...
    When the wind blows
    With 1,200 wind turbines due to be built in the UK this year, Mark Rowe explores the continuing controversy surrounding wind power and discusses the e...


NEVER MISS A STORY - follow Geographical

Want to stay up to date with breaking Geographical stories? Join the thousands following us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram and stay informed about the world.

More articles in NATURE...


With their horns still much-prized by poachers, will the revered…


Narwhals show a complex response to interaction with humans and…


The biodiversity of the Antarctic seafloor has been modelled for…


With growing fears over the negative impacts of excessive sunscreen…


Harmful ozone levels found at the Earth’s surface, or troposphere,…


Those concerned with external asylum applications to the EU might…


Cryptocurrencies might be setting the world’s digital economy on fire,…


A multilateral moratorium prevents Arctic Ocean fishing for 16 years,…


A global campaign is underway to turn a huge area…


From the iconic narrowboats meandering along picturesque British landscapes, to…


Warm and humid conditions are found to be the trigger…


Overfishing and climate change are edging seabirds such as the…


East African countries are sharing shipping data in order to…


How many elephants can you see? How many orang-utans are…


The ocean floor is being deformed under the weight of…


Progress on halting warming has not been great throughout 2017.…


Coral bleaching is widespread around the globe and as it…


Wales is the second best recycler in the world


A series of worrying reports by the Global Carbon Project…


While it was the impact on civilian populations that generated…