Our directory of things of interest

University Directory

COP21 Diaries: The case for a price

  • Written by  Marco Magrini
  • Published in Climate
James Hansen at COP21, Paris, France James Hansen at COP21, Paris, France Marco Magrini
03 Dec
Marco Magrini reports for Geographical on daily events at the COP21 UN climate change conference in Paris

James Hansen has got a doomsayer’s reputation, maybe for his lack of diplomatic skills, and not only because he made an explosive testimony before the US Congress in 1988 warning of climate change risks well in advance. As a climate scientist at NASA, a federal agency, he managed to publicly blame the Bush administration for trying to silence him. Even today, after his retirement, he isn’t holding his tongue at the UN climate change negotiations: ‘Without a carbon tax, the Paris agreement is broken,’ he bluntly says.

Fossil fuels are partially subsidised, Hansen argues, but their price does not include the cost of air and water pollution on human health. ‘The climate effects which are beginning to be significant, are also not included,’ he remarks. ‘The solution would be pretty straightforward: let’s add those costs to the price of fossil fuels. Not suddenly, but gradually over time.

‘I argue that it should be done across all fossil fuels, at the source: the domestic mine or the port of entry. I also argue this money should be given to the public, in equal amounts to all the legal resident of a country. Then, the household that does better than the average in limiting their carbon footprint, can actually make money.’ In his opinion, this would address the income inequality in the world too, since low-income people tend to have a lower carbon footprint. ‘People with big houses that fly around the world will pay more, but they can afford to do that.’

You can’t say the Paris talks are moving rapidly. After the declarations of the world’s presidents and kings, negotiations are back to their normal, sluggish pace

He makes the point that this would be a transparent, market-based solution, capable of stimulating the economy. ‘According to some studies,’ Hansen says, ‘if you had a fee of $10 a tonne of CO2 and you distributed money to the public, after ten years you would have an emission reduction of 30 per cent in the United States, and more than 50 per cent after 20 years. This would also spur the economy, creating three million new jobs in a decade.’

Hansen describes this as the only viable international approach. ‘You cannot ask each of the 195 countries to individually limit their emissions,’ he argues, implicitly criticising the agreement being negotiated in Paris. On the contrary, he adds, ‘if you put a rising carbon price on fossil fuels, you only need to have a few of the major players on board. Those countries that do not want to have that fee, would put a border duty on products and, furthermore, we will rebate to our manufacturers the carbon fee when they export a product to a non-participating nation. This is a fair way to rapidly move us out of fossil fuels.’

You can’t say the Paris talks are moving rapidly. After the imposing, and maybe boastful, declarations of the world’s presidents and kings, the negotiations are back to their normal, sluggish pace. ‘This is the rhythm of diplomacy, get used to it,’ a European delegate sarcastically tells me.

The prospective agreement to be signed next week – which prescribes voluntary, not compulsory, emission reductions from most of the world’s countries – doesn’t add up to limiting the temperature rise below the famed 2°C mark. Hansen’s most recent paper warns of a possible feedback loop in Antarctica: cooler freshwater from melting glaciers may force warmer, saltier water underneath the ice sheets, speeding up the melting rate. ‘You can’t never rule out tipping points,’ he cautions.

The former NASA scientist may not be completely right. The trouble is, he can’t be completely wrong.

Geographical Week

Get the best of Geographical delivered straight to your inbox every Friday.

Subscribe to Geographical!

Adventure Canada


Aberystwyth University University of Greenwich The University of Winchester




Travel the Unknown


Like longer reads? Try our in-depth dossiers that provide a comprehensive view of each topic

  • National Clean Air Day
    For National Clean Air Day, Geographical brings together stories about air pollution and the kind of solutions needed to tackle it ...
    The Air That We Breathe
    Cities the world over are struggling to improve air quality as scandals surrounding diesel car emissions come to light and the huge health costs of po...
    Diabetes: The World at Risk
    Diabetes is often thought of as a ‘western’ problem, one linked to the developed world’s overindulgence in fatty foods and chronic lack of physi...
    Mexico City: boom town
    Twenty years ago, Mexico City was considered the ultimate urban disaster. But, recent political and economic reforms have transformed it into a hub of...
    The Nuclear Power Struggle
    The UK appears to be embracing nuclear, a huge U-turn on government policy from just two years ago. Yet this seems to be going against the grain globa...


NEVER MISS A STORY - Follow Geographical on Social

Want to stay up to date with breaking Geographical stories? Join the thousands following us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram and stay informed about the world.

More articles in NATURE...


NGOs shine a light on the underreporting of wildlife crime…


Pioneering laser photography is being used by scientists on the…


Annual competition looks to celebrate island life in all its…


Increasing interest in offshore aquaculture is dividing environmentalists


Well-meaning promises don’t always have positive outcomes. Marco Magrini finds…


The RSPB introduces a new hotline for reporting the unlawful…


With the death earlier this week of the world’s last…


The essence of street photography is its raw, unfiltered, unstaged…


For Marco Magrini, a tax on fossil fuels would be…


Half of animal species in world’s most biodiverse areas could…


Four-year project to reestablish safe breeding grounds for seabirds on…


First global atlas of soil bacteria reveals a small minority…


Scientists discover how shrubs are dominating the Arctic tundra


War and conservation have a complicated relationship, with two studies…


Why is Europe so cold right now? Marco Magrini suggests…


Threatened Californian owls are suffering from digesting rat poison administered…


With the majority of the ocean still remaining undiscovered, a…


Belize bans offshore oil extraction to protect the second longest…


With their horns still much-prized by poachers, will the revered…


Narwhals show a complex response to interaction with humans and…